Advance Directive: How Patient Wishes Guide Care
What happens if a patient cannot communicate a treatment decision? Advance care directives provide a way to record preferences and appoint someone to speak for the patient when decisions cannot be made or communicated personally.
A living will describes treatment wishes; a health care proxy is the person authorized to make decisions under the applicable document and state law. These advance planning directives work best when the care team and the appointed person can find them and understand the patient’s priorities.
Advance Directives: Two complementary documents
An advance directive for health care is a legal document used to communicate choices about future medical care. The term commonly covers a living will and a durable power of attorney for health care. Depending on the state, these may be separate forms or parts of one document.
The documents address decisions that can arise after an accident, a serious illness, or a decline in the ability to make decisions. While a patient has decision-making capacity, the patient ordinarily makes their own choices and can discuss or change them. A written plan gives others guidance if that ability is lost; the conditions for using the documents depend on state law and the terms of the form.
Advance directives are useful at any adult age, because a medical crisis is not limited to older people. Completing a form is one part of planning. Conversations about values and likely treatment choices give these advance health directives context.
What a living will says
A living will records the treatment a person would or would not want in specified circumstances. For example, it may address cardiopulmonary resuscitation (CPR), a breathing machine, artificial nutrition or hydration, and comfort-focused care. The form and the situations it covers depend on state law.
Specific instructions are more useful when they describe both the treatment and the circumstances. A person might consider how they would view a temporary treatment while recovery is assessed, as well as treatment intended to sustain life when recovery is unlikely. A clinician can explain what those treatments involve and how outcomes may vary.
A living will is different from a will that distributes property after death. The former guides medical care during life; the latter concerns an estate.
What a health care proxy does
A durable power of attorney for health care names a health care agent, also called a proxy or surrogate in some settings. This person can discuss the clinical situation with the care team and make authorized decisions when the patient cannot. The document may describe the agent’s powers and limits, and the applicable law determines how the appointment operates.
The agent may need to decide about a situation the written instructions did not anticipate. Knowing the patient’s values helps the agent speak on the patient’s behalf. A trusted person who is willing to take the role, can be reached, and can communicate with clinicians is a practical choice. An alternate can be named in case the first choice is unavailable, if the state form permits it.
Before completing the appointment, the patient should ask the proposed agent whether they are willing to serve. The patient can then discuss views about treatment, acceptable tradeoffs, and whom the agent should contact. The National Institute on Aging’s guide to choosing a proxy offers questions for that conversation.
An illustrative situation
Consider this advance directive example: Maria states in a living will that she would accept a short trial of a breathing machine in a defined situation, but would not want it continued indefinitely if her doctors determine recovery is not expected. She names her brother as her health care agent and discusses what she means by an acceptable outcome.
After an accident, Maria cannot make decisions. Her clinicians assess her condition and explain the options. Her brother refers to her written instructions and their conversation when making decisions within his authority. The example illustrates how the two documents can work together; actual wording, medical facts, and state requirements affect any particular case.
Find the right form and make it available
State rules differ on forms, witnesses, notarization, and who may serve as an agent. Start with the state health department or state attorney general’s website, and look for its current advance care planning forms and completion instructions. The National Institute on Aging’s overview also points readers toward state forms. A local attorney or legal aid organization can help interpret requirements when a situation is complicated or involves more than one state.
Ask the doctor’s office or hospital how to submit a completed document and whether its records include a current copy. A facility may have its own process for scanning documents and identifying the agent. Give copies to the agent, alternate, and relevant clinicians, and tell family members where the original is kept.
A do-not-resuscitate order is a separate medical order concerning CPR; a living will alone may not serve the same function in every setting. Discuss any desired order with a clinician. Review advance medical instructions after a move, a major health change, or a change in the chosen agent, and replace outdated copies when the documents change.
As a first step today, locate the current forms and signing instructions on the relevant state health department website, then arrange a conversation with a clinician and a possible agent.
